Magic At Your Door Disney Subscription Box Reviews

All reviews are from verified buyers of Magic At Your Door products who have responded to an automated review request email sent to all customers after receiving their order. Reviews are posted automatically without modification, and no reviews are hidden or deleted.
Based on 116 reviews
Awesome box!!

I’ve tried other Disney box subscriptions and this is by far the best one! They took in consideration all of my preferences and chose some amazing items. The plus side was that they included items for my daughter (3) and hit it out of the park for her! My favorite item were the earrings that I received. My daughters favorite was a Minnie hoodie that come inside of a drawstring bag! I definitely will be ordering from MAYD again!!! ❤️

Amazing box

I absolutely loved my magical af box magic at your door does not disappoint they are absolutely amazing thank you guys soooo much ❤❤❤

First box, AMAZING BOX

Seriously you guys! I was worried I would get items I didn’t like. You really read our preferences and try super hard to get everyone what they like. i can’t say enough good things. You’ve definitely have me hooked. The Minnie ears are my very first pair, and they’re my number one choice!! And the wallet to match is to die for! The MCU pillow I can’t wait to show off to my brother. The bracelet is my first Alex and Ani, and I love that it says “just keep swimming”. The pen is amazing bc I said I love thing either he iconic Disney foods on it. I’m obsessed with shot glasses. And the Muppets pin mean so much. I love the muppets and this is my first Disney pin! The mug was awesome bc I love Chip. The Starbucks ornament was amazing. If I’m gonna start a plush collection, Lotso is definitely the best to start with! I really can’t say enough good things.

Beautiful bronze goodness

I was so excited when MAYD added some more affordable, but still customizable subscription tiers. And my first magic box did not disappoint!
I do kind of wish that there was a packing slip with all of the retail values, especially for the items that aren't covered on the included chart, but that's just because I have a subscription box unboxing channel and I like to see the value I'm getting. As an AP, I'm usually looking for a Disney box to give me a 110% value compared to what I pay to account for the discount I get at the parks. With an estimated retail value of almost $90, this $75 bronze box definitely delivered on that front. And, MAYD includes shipping (which other boxes charge more for) in their pricing, so really, it was an even bigger value margin.
As for the actual items, they all fell in line with my preferences (even though some prompted me to go in and be even more specific), and there was an awesome variety of items and price points, from a fun pen and sticky notes, all the way up to a Loungefly crossbody! Yes, I got a Loungefly purse in my bronze box, which I was stunned by! Not to mention some ears that I think I marked on my wishlist and a pin that I already have, but am fine having a duplicate of.
I was very impressed that they were able to work with my very narrow preferences for item types and characters. I love Disney, but I really try to keep my merch more grown-up and usable, which is sometimes a fine line to walk. Looking forward to getting another bronze box and maybe someday saving my pennies and trying silver or gold.


Absolutely loved it! This box never disappoints, every Disney enthusiast or collector needs this box! Keep up the good work!

It's like you know me.

First box I have ever ordered and every item was amazing. Loved every item in my box. Received my first pair of minnie mouse ears and will take them on my upcoming Disney trip. Love the baby yoda socks. Looking forward to box two.

So happy with my box!

My box was everything I dreamed it would be and more. Items from my wish list were included, as well as other items that fit within my preferences. I am very pleased with this service and highly recommend other Disney lovers give it a go!

hope future magic

i like great good unboxing .. cool things .. also i love dinsey and i like to every monthly but once skip bec i am vacation save so also my grandson only curious when i get unboxing he go freak !! love Dinsey magic .!! thank you and thanks i suspirse to siliver member ! hope future upgrade who people more come imporve ..grow grow come magic!!

Box number 2!

I’m even happier with my second box! I love that some of my wishlist items were included as well as a couple of nice surprises that really did fit my preferences. Everything made me smile and I am so grateful for a magical touch to my month!

First box was a wonderful experience!

Wow is all all I can say. My first box was so wonderful. Loved absolutley eveything. I feel like I'm a picky person. So I wasn't sure if I would like a subscription box. I do love the wishlist feature. But this time I added two of the same type of item. So it could be more of a surprise. Last month I really really wanted the dalmation back pack. So I just added that one item. Thanks MAYD!❤

Gold level box review

Magic at your door is a great subscription box at any value level. You always get value above what you spend and very fun unique items you may or may not be able to get otherwise. I’ve been with them a year and a half and have never been disappointed. I highly recommend this subscription box.

So Magical!

My daughter loved her one time box! You can tell the thought put into each item that was chosen for her box. It definitely made her birthday that much more magical! Thank you MAYD!!!


I have had 3 boxes and have never been disappointed!!!

Great Box

Overall, my box was amazing but there were just some things that I was not super thrilled with and so I modify my preferences as the shipments come in, and they continue to get better with each change. I can't wait for next month.

Home run once again!

Having our Disney trip in Nov we needed the boost from a perfectly presented January Gold Box. Completely based on our unique preferences, every item was a winner! The extra magic of their new pin series was an added dose of magic! Can't wait until Febuary!

Love my subscription box!!!

I just signed up in January and got my first box and absolutely love it!! All the items are so perfect and I can’t wait to get my next box and so on and so on!! Thank u Mike so so much for picking out such amazing items!! This box is the epitome of Disney Magic!!

The Best Day of the Month

The box always contains my favorites! And I can adjust my favorites - if I have enough coffee cups, I can just uncheck it on my preferences.

I rarely receive something that I don't like or cannot use.

Magically yours,

Disney Magic Box Subscription
More Bang For Your Buck

I am ashamed to say this was not my first choice in Disney subscription boxes 🙈 I originally started with another company and after how much I paid and the 💩 merchandise I received I knew it was time to make a change. I'm upset that I didn't find this company sooner! There is always transparency and Mike and 001 will always try their best to make things right when you are unsatisfied or if an item arrives broken. There list of likes and dislikes can take a minute or two to fill out but that's what makes this company great to ensure you get items geared to your likes. Don't waste your time and money with other companies! Magic At Your Door will definitely give you more Bang For Your Buck!

Best “box” ever

Listen. You can look and hope and dream that you could find products this amazing in your subscription boxes, but you won’t. I have tried multiple box subscriptions in the past and NOTHING compares to MAYD! Hand-picked and sometimes even specifically requested items, will be in your box. Preferences are followed and I have never had a hard time communicating with the MAYD team. BEST “BOX” EXPERIENCE EVER!

A box full of happiness!

If you love disney then this is the subscription box for you! I love how customizable Magic At Your Door is and though I'm pretty new, they have not disappointed me yet. The gold level has high priced merch and now you get exclusive MAYD pins to collect!

Amazing box!

Once again Mike and the 001 team did an amazing job!! Video of unboxing at autumnlovesdisney on YouTube

Amazing Box and Value

This is my first gold level box and it did not disappoint! The olaf backpack is too cute and so excited for the 2020 pins and lanyard for my son who is graduating this year! The wishlist is so easy to use and has so many items to choose from and the new monthly pin is so beautiful! I highly recommend this box to everyone!

Pure Excellence

Best Disney subscription box ever!! Every box i have received has been excellent!!


Loved everything I received. The wallet is beautiful and I love the Stitch throw blanket. I wrote that I would love more blankets and you guys listened! Thank you!

Best Disney subscription box

Every month this box brings to your home the best Disney items on market (no fillers). Customization is great and you always receive items you like. I'm from Italy so i have to use a shipping service to receive the box but it worth every penny i spent because every month is a wonderful surprise when it's time to open the box with my girlfriend. Thank you Magic at your door!!!